I was scooting through my apartment building’s basement (a wonder in systems and architecture) on my way to pick up a package at the Super’s Office. My path crosses an alleyway in our complex where trash is collected prior to moving out onto the street, and I saw this terrifying object!!
I was frozen in terror. A Disney Princess kitchen set. Not only does little girl get to learn household roles, she gets to feel like she’s engaging in a precious, pink activity while doing it (am I reaffirming gender stereotypes myself here by assuming this didn’t belong to a boy?). I certainly begged an Easy Bake Oven when I was a kid, but my mother was careful not to encourage role-stereotyping. I think my only toy kitchen equipment was a small groovy set of orange, green, and brown toy Tupperware, some of which is still used by my parents for their lunches.
Culinary endeavors are certainly having a moment of fame here as Americans re-learn the importance of good food after the tragedies of the 20th century. I think the P-word is doing our girls a disservice. If she’s interested in cooking, how about getting her to stir cookie dough and actually make something? (or something healthy, if you object to cookies). I was equally disturbed by Goldie Blox, engineering toys for girls. The premise from this Kickstarter campaign is that in order to interest girls in science, you must wrap it in pink and sparkles and cute puppies and ribbons. Really? Have all our toys just become more gendered? I don’t remember anything particularly girl or boy about Tinkertoys, those sharp-edged all metal Tonka Toys, or my favorite, Lincoln Logs. I could play with Lincoln Logs for hours. (ok! full disclosure: so I did have Barbie and My Little Pony – but my brother and I spent hours playing with Matchbox cars too).
Read my post “Hold the Tulle: I’m Anti-Princess” about actually talking to girls about their brain, rather than indicating that their value is appearance-based.
Stop the fantasy homemaker madness!!!
I’ve never understood the princess and pink thing. When I played Cherry Ames, my dad said, Be a doctor.
The toy aisles in the big box stores just make me think Backlash.
3.5 years ago I would have agreed with you wholeheartedly. Now however, if I had seen that kitchen waiting for the trash collection, I would have swooped it up and given it to my daughter who would have sighed “it is just what I’ve always wanted”. She was born into a house with cars, trains, sports equipment and enough arms and armor for a militia and our world has gotten progressively pinker and sparkly with every passing year. As the ultimate tomboy I figure that this is some sort of revenge. I couldn’t believe the stereotyping of the Lego Friends line when they first came out but my nieces love them and I never saw my daughter spend so much time playing with Legos as when I took her to the new Legoland Discovery Center in Yonkers. While her brothers raced lego cars she built lego cupcakes and baked them in the room they set up to look like a kitchen. We have Legos without end at home but she wanted pink legos. Now they are her favorite plaything. Just wait Becky…!
I fully admit I’m not a mother of boys or girls! But the whole tutu movement scares me.
p.s. we go to Costco (and anywhere else for that matter) in full princess regalia, sometimes though accessorized with her shiny silver soccer shin guards and pink cleats.
When the time goes you’ll see… you will just have to go with the flow.
I want a tutu.
But..if we don’t have the pink stuff…what will I get my son? He has insisted on the pink things since he was about 4. After a brief fling with red, he is back to pink. I had to buy the pink flowered notebooks for him for school this year! He wears a lot of pink, too. At 14, I’ve been asking him about why he likes the societally named “girl” stuff (no worries, we were both clear on the non-judgment), and he says, “I do like pink, and I like pushing boundaries). So…shrug. You can raise kids to like what they like. I have one girl who avoids pink (and wants to carry a musket), one who embraces it. She likes Disney Princess stuff, war movies, and was excited to go to a gun range and fire a few different guns. I like pink, biking, avoided that range trip, and detest war movies. The oldest is now a nanny, cooks for her kids, but doesn’t much enjoy it, the youngest is a boy, who enjoys cooking, especially baking. They make smaller spoons and bowls for kids to bake with, they can help! Limit TV, strictly, when they are little, and it all works itself out, or, at least, it worked for us!
I just remember another issue. With Legos, they were made in primary colors, the colors society drilled into kids’ heads were for boys’ toys. adding jewel tones and pastels gives girls’ “permission” to use them. If they wanted to really improve things, sets should be mixed of all the colors, and show ads of boys and girls building with all colors.
Also, there are now pink, green, blue, red and colorful sporting equipment…much more than there used to be. Once girls really started playing as much as the boys, the advertising folks realized that to make their products more appealing, they needed to appeal to all the senses, and have many colors, to appeal to everyone (boys, too)…the higher quality stuff is more generically colored.
I had a black and grey exercise computer. I hated it, annoyed that practical stuff was always in colors to appeal to guys. Was I ever glad when I lost it, and went to replace it, to find them with the watch part styled and colored to appeal to women (various colors, including greys and blues, and hot pink). Mine is fuchsia! Wearing a black or grey piece of equipment pains me….(rather like those who see numbers as colors, it is important to me to like the color I wear). I’m annoyed that the new recumbent trike I want is ony available in orange. I’ll have to seriously cover it in decals, and use a rainbow flag…
I always love your posts Colleen! More color. (I just prefer orange to pink)